In Jalen Hurts vs. Gardner Minshew QB debate, answer is clear for Eagles
There is a quarterback controversy in the Philadelphia Eagles locker room.
Gardner Minshew, who was picked by the Washington Redskins on day two of this year’s NFL Draft, will be starting for the team only to have second-year player Jalen Hurts take over if he falters. The question at hand? Who should start when both are healthy? The answer may seem clear from an outside perspective but not everyone agrees. In particular, some people contend that there is no real debate and Nick Foles needs to return as QB1 with ZERO excuses given about how much he has been injured or any other issue between him and Minshews’ performance during training camp or preseason games.,
The “gardner minshew stats” is a debate that has been going on for some time. The answer is clear for Eagles fans, as they should be rooting for Gardner Minshew to win the job.
EAST RUTHERFORD, N.J. (CBSNewYork) — On Monday, it will be one year since Carson Wentz was benched in favor of Jalen Hurts.
The Philadelphia Eagles were rumored to be considering a quarterback change weeks before that, as Wentz battled through his worst season to date. For a while, then-coach Doug Pederson hesitated, knowing the gravity and possible ramifications of such a choice. In Week 13, with the Eagles behind the Green Bay Packers 20-6 and the offense stuck in neutral once again, Pederson turned to Hurts early in the third quarter.
Hurts resurrected the offense and breathed new life into the season. In his first career start the following week, he defeated the New Orleans Saints 10-2, and despite inconsistent performance over the last three games, he proved to be the more productive quarterback of the two. However, the switch to Hurts put in motion a series of events that culminated in the trade of an unhappy Wentz and the firing of Pederson and the majority of his staff.
The lessons learned from that circumstance should be used a year later, when the Eagles quarterback issue is once again being discussed. In lieu of Hurts, Gardner Minshew started Sunday and lit up the New York Jets, finishing 20-of-25 for 242 yards and two touchdowns in a 33-18 victory. The passing game was effective, and tight end Dallas Goedert (six receptions, 105 yards, two touchdowns) had a career day, piqueing interest in what the offense may look like with Minshew at the helm in the long run.
Here’s how the playoff bracket currently stands, as well as the possible outcomes. • Who’s in the playoff picture right now? • The Playoff Machine on ESPN » • Football Power Index » | Standings
This isn’t a situation where a team’s starting quarterback is holding them back. There isn’t the same sense of urgency as last year to get things going.
Even if there was, moving to Minshew would be the wrong choice. Unlike other positions where changing starters may be done without much repercussion, switching quarterbacks can have an irrevocable effect. It may lead to a schism in the locker room, causing players to question the coaching staff and the whole business. When a demotioned quarterback has established himself as a respected team leader, like Hurts has, the odds of backlash are much higher.
With Wentz, whatever remaining faith he had in the organization washed away the instant he was replaced in the lineup. Testing their connection with their current QB1 is not worth the risk.
Hurts was given the reins after Wentz was traded over the summer. With the Eagles holding upwards of three first-round selections in April’s draft — money they can use to pursue a quarterback if they so choose — this season became entirely about determining if Hurts could be the long-term solution.
The Eagles’ most pressing question is still unanswered. The regular season is still four games away, giving Philadelphia four more chances to examine Hurts before making a franchise-altering choice.
Minshew has the potential to be a good quarterback. He has 39 touchdowns and 11 interceptions in his career. On Sunday, he looked fantastic. However, it was against the Jets, who have a reputation for making opposition quarterbacks seem great. According to ESPN’s Football Power Index, the Jets’ defense was the worst in the NFL through the first 12 weeks, even before giving up 418 yards to the Eagles on Sunday.
Minshew mania is entertaining. It’s reasonable to question how the offense will look with him at the helm in their upcoming game versus Washington.
But, if you go back far enough in this team’s history, you’ll see that rash quarterback selections often backfire.
Watch This Video-
The “Gardner Minshew contract” is the answer to the question of who should be the starting quarterback for the Philadelphia Eagles. The team signed Gardner Minshew to a 3 year deal worth $7 million. Reference: gardner minshew contract.
- jalen hurts
- gardner minshew